Kingscliff Triathlon II 2024

Aquabike Standard Distance
Date
01 Dec 2024
Location
Lions Park
Kingscliff, New South Wales, Australia

Distances shown in ft/mi » change to m/km

Swim Distance
0.9 mi
Bike Distance
24.9 mi (with 220 ft elevation gain)

Ride it virtually How does it work?

Results
|
|

Results

Overall Male Female
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Ethan FITZSIMMONS
M U16
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:01:56 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:00:54
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
290
Swim
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
2 Neil MAKEPEACE
M 55-59

0 Kudos
00:13:40 (3.)
+00:01:13 (+9,8%)
00:02:24 (3.)
+00:00:28 (+24,1%)
00:49:52 (2.)
+00:03:22 (+7,2%)
01:05:56
+00:05:02 (+8,3%)
250
Swim
00:13:40 (3.)
+00:01:13 (+9,8%)
Bike
00:49:52 (2.)
+00:03:22 (+7,2%)
3 Claim Charley O´BRIEN
F 30-34
00:13:09 (2.)
+00:00:42 (+5,6%)
00:02:18 (2.)
+00:00:22 (+19,0%)
00:54:28 (4.)
+00:07:58 (+17,1%)
01:09:56
+00:09:02 (+14,8%)
217
Swim
00:13:09 (2.)
+00:00:42 (+5,6%)
Bike
00:54:28 (4.)
+00:07:58 (+17,1%)
4 Claim Joanne COLJA
F 55-59
00:15:22 (6.)
+00:02:55 (+23,4%)
00:02:35 (6.)
+00:00:39 (+33,6%)
00:54:08 (3.)
+00:07:38 (+16,4%)
01:12:07
+00:11:13 (+18,4%)
197
Swim
00:15:22 (6.)
+00:02:55 (+23,4%)
Bike
00:54:08 (3.)
+00:07:38 (+16,4%)
5 Claim Glen SUSSMAN
M 50-54
00:16:02 (8.)
+00:03:35 (+28,8%)
00:02:35 (7.)
+00:00:39 (+33,6%)
00:54:44 (5.)
+00:08:14 (+17,7%)
01:13:23
+00:12:29 (+20,5%)
181
Swim
00:16:02 (8.)
+00:03:35 (+28,8%)
Bike
00:54:44 (5.)
+00:08:14 (+17,7%)
6 Claim Liz MELLON
F 60-64
00:16:35 (11.)
+00:04:08 (+33,2%)
00:02:53 (9.)
+00:00:57 (+49,1%)
00:54:58 (6.)
+00:08:28 (+18,2%)
01:14:27
+00:13:33 (+22,2%)
170
Swim
00:16:35 (11.)
+00:04:08 (+33,2%)
Bike
00:54:58 (6.)
+00:08:28 (+18,2%)
7 Claim Ty PERRIN
M 35-39
00:14:58 (4.)
+00:02:31 (+20,2%)
00:03:44 (12.)
+00:01:48 (+93,1%)
00:56:26 (7.)
+00:09:56 (+21,4%)
01:15:09
+00:14:15 (+23,4%)
160
Swim
00:14:58 (4.)
+00:02:31 (+20,2%)
Bike
00:56:26 (7.)
+00:09:56 (+21,4%)
8 Claim Niamh RYAN
F 25-29
00:15:46 (7.)
+00:03:19 (+26,6%)
00:02:36 (8.)
+00:00:40 (+34,5%)
00:58:19 (9.)
+00:11:49 (+25,4%)
01:16:42
+00:15:48 (+25,9%)
150
Swim
00:15:46 (7.)
+00:03:19 (+26,6%)
Bike
00:58:19 (9.)
+00:11:49 (+25,4%)
9 Claim Janine HARVEY
F 40-44
00:17:46 (13.)
+00:05:19 (+42,7%)
00:02:32 (5.)
+00:00:36 (+31,0%)
00:58:49 (10.)
+00:12:19 (+26,5%)
01:19:09
+00:18:15 (+30,0%)
138
Swim
00:17:46 (13.)
+00:05:19 (+42,7%)
Bike
00:58:49 (10.)
+00:12:19 (+26,5%)
10 Claim Keon MODINI
M 25-29
00:16:09 (9.)
+00:03:42 (+29,7%)
00:03:30 (11.)
+00:01:34 (+81,0%)
00:59:31 (12.)
+00:13:01 (+28,0%)
01:19:12
+00:18:18 (+30,0%)
131
Swim
00:16:09 (9.)
+00:03:42 (+29,7%)
Bike
00:59:31 (12.)
+00:13:01 (+28,0%)
11 Claim Sean CROTTY
M 30-34
00:17:25 (12.)
+00:04:58 (+39,9%)
00:03:00 (10.)
+00:01:04 (+55,2%)
00:58:59 (11.)
+00:12:29 (+26,8%)
01:19:25
+00:18:31 (+30,4%)
126
Swim
00:17:25 (12.)
+00:04:58 (+39,9%)
Bike
00:58:59 (11.)
+00:12:29 (+26,8%)
12 Claim Joan SHEATHER
F 60-64
00:19:18 (15.)
+00:06:51 (+55,0%)
00:02:28 (4.)
+00:00:32 (+27,6%)
00:59:35 (13.)
+00:13:05 (+28,1%)
01:21:23
+00:20:29 (+33,6%)
118
Swim
00:19:18 (15.)
+00:06:51 (+55,0%)
Bike
00:59:35 (13.)
+00:13:05 (+28,1%)
13 Claim Clare JOHNSTON
F 65-69
00:22:27 (16.)
+00:10:00 (+80,3%)
00:04:00 (14.)
+00:02:04 (+106,9%)
00:57:09 (8.)
+00:10:39 (+22,9%)
01:23:38
+00:22:44 (+37,3%)
110
Swim
00:22:27 (16.)
+00:10:00 (+80,3%)
Bike
00:57:09 (8.)
+00:10:39 (+22,9%)
14 Claim Lachlan HARNETT
M 20-24
00:16:34 (10.)
+00:04:07 (+33,1%)
00:07:30 (16.)
+00:05:34 (+287,9%)
00:59:46 (14.)
+00:13:16 (+28,5%)
01:23:52
+00:22:58 (+37,7%)
105
Swim
00:16:34 (10.)
+00:04:07 (+33,1%)
Bike
00:59:46 (14.)
+00:13:16 (+28,5%)
15 Claim Bebe LEWIS
F 25-29
00:15:21 (5.)
+00:02:54 (+23,3%)
00:03:48 (13.)
+00:01:52 (+96,6%)
01:05:09 (16.)
+00:18:39 (+40,1%)
01:24:20
+00:23:26 (+38,5%)
101
Swim
00:15:21 (5.)
+00:02:54 (+23,3%)
Bike
01:05:09 (16.)
+00:18:39 (+40,1%)
16 Claim Susan DWYER
F 65-69
00:18:36 (14.)
+00:06:09 (+49,4%)
00:04:28 (15.)
+00:02:32 (+131,0%)
01:04:41 (15.)
+00:18:11 (+39,1%)
01:27:47
+00:26:53 (+44,1%)
92
Swim
00:18:36 (14.)
+00:06:09 (+49,4%)
Bike
01:04:41 (15.)
+00:18:11 (+39,1%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Ethan FITZSIMMONS
M U16
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:01:56 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:00:54
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
290
Swim
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
2 Neil MAKEPEACE
M 55-59

0 Kudos
00:13:40 (2.)
+00:01:13 (+9,8%)
00:02:24 (2.)
+00:00:28 (+24,1%)
00:49:52 (2.)
+00:03:22 (+7,2%)
01:05:56
+00:05:02 (+8,3%)
250
Swim
00:13:40 (2.)
+00:01:13 (+9,8%)
Bike
00:49:52 (2.)
+00:03:22 (+7,2%)
3 Claim Glen SUSSMAN
M 50-54
00:16:02 (4.)
+00:03:35 (+28,8%)
00:02:35 (3.)
+00:00:39 (+33,6%)
00:54:44 (3.)
+00:08:14 (+17,7%)
01:13:23
+00:12:29 (+20,5%)
181
Swim
00:16:02 (4.)
+00:03:35 (+28,8%)
Bike
00:54:44 (3.)
+00:08:14 (+17,7%)
4 Claim Ty PERRIN
M 35-39
00:14:58 (3.)
+00:02:31 (+20,2%)
00:03:44 (6.)
+00:01:48 (+93,1%)
00:56:26 (4.)
+00:09:56 (+21,4%)
01:15:09
+00:14:15 (+23,4%)
160
Swim
00:14:58 (3.)
+00:02:31 (+20,2%)
Bike
00:56:26 (4.)
+00:09:56 (+21,4%)
5 Claim Keon MODINI
M 25-29
00:16:09 (5.)
+00:03:42 (+29,7%)
00:03:30 (5.)
+00:01:34 (+81,0%)
00:59:31 (6.)
+00:13:01 (+28,0%)
01:19:12
+00:18:18 (+30,0%)
131
Swim
00:16:09 (5.)
+00:03:42 (+29,7%)
Bike
00:59:31 (6.)
+00:13:01 (+28,0%)
6 Claim Sean CROTTY
M 30-34
00:17:25 (7.)
+00:04:58 (+39,9%)
00:03:00 (4.)
+00:01:04 (+55,2%)
00:58:59 (5.)
+00:12:29 (+26,8%)
01:19:25
+00:18:31 (+30,4%)
126
Swim
00:17:25 (7.)
+00:04:58 (+39,9%)
Bike
00:58:59 (5.)
+00:12:29 (+26,8%)
7 Claim Lachlan HARNETT
M 20-24
00:16:34 (6.)
+00:04:07 (+33,1%)
00:07:30 (7.)
+00:05:34 (+287,9%)
00:59:46 (7.)
+00:13:16 (+28,5%)
01:23:52
+00:22:58 (+37,7%)
105
Swim
00:16:34 (6.)
+00:04:07 (+33,1%)
Bike
00:59:46 (7.)
+00:13:16 (+28,5%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Charley O´BRIEN
F 30-34
00:13:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:18 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:54:28 (2.)
+00:00:20 (+0,6%)
01:09:56
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
217
Swim
00:13:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:54:28 (2.)
+00:00:20 (+0,6%)
2 Claim Joanne COLJA
F 55-59
00:15:22 (3.)
+00:02:13 (+16,9%)
00:02:35 (4.)
+00:00:17 (+12,3%)
00:54:08 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:12:07
+00:02:11 (+3,1%)
197
Swim
00:15:22 (3.)
+00:02:13 (+16,9%)
Bike
00:54:08 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
3 Claim Liz MELLON
F 60-64
00:16:35 (5.)
+00:03:26 (+26,1%)
00:02:53 (6.)
+00:00:35 (+25,4%)
00:54:58 (3.)
+00:00:50 (+1,5%)
01:14:27
+00:04:31 (+6,5%)
170
Swim
00:16:35 (5.)
+00:03:26 (+26,1%)
Bike
00:54:58 (3.)
+00:00:50 (+1,5%)
4 Claim Niamh RYAN
F 25-29
00:15:46 (4.)
+00:02:37 (+19,9%)
00:02:36 (5.)
+00:00:18 (+13,0%)
00:58:19 (5.)
+00:04:11 (+7,7%)
01:16:42
+00:06:46 (+9,7%)
150
Swim
00:15:46 (4.)
+00:02:37 (+19,9%)
Bike
00:58:19 (5.)
+00:04:11 (+7,7%)
5 Claim Janine HARVEY
F 40-44
00:17:46 (6.)
+00:04:37 (+35,1%)
00:02:32 (3.)
+00:00:14 (+10,1%)
00:58:49 (6.)
+00:04:41 (+8,7%)
01:19:09
+00:09:13 (+13,2%)
138
Swim
00:17:46 (6.)
+00:04:37 (+35,1%)
Bike
00:58:49 (6.)
+00:04:41 (+8,7%)
6 Claim Joan SHEATHER
F 60-64
00:19:18 (8.)
+00:06:09 (+46,8%)
00:02:28 (2.)
+00:00:10 (+7,2%)
00:59:35 (7.)
+00:05:27 (+10,1%)
01:21:23
+00:11:27 (+16,4%)
118
Swim
00:19:18 (8.)
+00:06:09 (+46,8%)
Bike
00:59:35 (7.)
+00:05:27 (+10,1%)
7 Claim Clare JOHNSTON
F 65-69
00:22:27 (9.)
+00:09:18 (+70,7%)
00:04:00 (8.)
+00:01:42 (+73,9%)
00:57:09 (4.)
+00:03:01 (+5,6%)
01:23:38
+00:13:42 (+19,6%)
110
Swim
00:22:27 (9.)
+00:09:18 (+70,7%)
Bike
00:57:09 (4.)
+00:03:01 (+5,6%)
8 Claim Bebe LEWIS
F 25-29
00:15:21 (2.)
+00:02:12 (+16,7%)
00:03:48 (7.)
+00:01:30 (+65,2%)
01:05:09 (9.)
+00:11:01 (+20,4%)
01:24:20
+00:14:24 (+20,6%)
101
Swim
00:15:21 (2.)
+00:02:12 (+16,7%)
Bike
01:05:09 (9.)
+00:11:01 (+20,4%)
9 Claim Susan DWYER
F 65-69
00:18:36 (7.)
+00:05:27 (+41,4%)
00:04:28 (9.)
+00:02:10 (+94,2%)
01:04:41 (8.)
+00:10:33 (+19,5%)
01:27:47
+00:17:51 (+25,5%)
92
Swim
00:18:36 (7.)
+00:05:27 (+41,4%)
Bike
01:04:41 (8.)
+00:10:33 (+19,5%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Niamh RYAN
F 25-29
00:15:46 (2.)
+00:00:25 (+2,7%)
00:02:36 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:58:19 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:16:42
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
150
Swim
00:15:46 (2.)
+00:00:25 (+2,7%)
Bike
00:58:19 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
2 Claim Bebe LEWIS
F 25-29
00:15:21 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:03:48 (2.)
+00:01:12 (+46,2%)
01:05:09 (2.)
+00:06:50 (+11,7%)
01:24:20
+00:07:38 (+10,0%)
101
Swim
00:15:21 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
01:05:09 (2.)
+00:06:50 (+11,7%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Charley O´BRIEN
F 30-34
00:13:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:18 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:54:28 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:09:56
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
217
Swim
00:13:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:54:28 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Janine HARVEY
F 40-44
00:17:46 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:32 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:58:49 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:19:09
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
138
Swim
00:17:46 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:58:49 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Joanne COLJA
F 55-59
00:15:22 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:35 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:54:08 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:12:07
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
197
Swim
00:15:22 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:54:08 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Liz MELLON
F 60-64
00:16:35 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:53 (2.)
+00:00:25 (+16,9%)
00:54:58 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:14:27
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
170
Swim
00:16:35 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:54:58 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
2 Claim Joan SHEATHER
F 60-64
00:19:18 (2.)
+00:02:43 (+16,4%)
00:02:28 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:59:35 (2.)
+00:04:37 (+8,4%)
01:21:23
+00:06:56 (+9,3%)
118
Swim
00:19:18 (2.)
+00:02:43 (+16,4%)
Bike
00:59:35 (2.)
+00:04:37 (+8,4%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Clare JOHNSTON
F 65-69
00:22:27 (2.)
+00:03:51 (+20,7%)
00:04:00 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:57:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:23:38
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
110
Swim
00:22:27 (2.)
+00:03:51 (+20,7%)
Bike
00:57:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
2 Claim Susan DWYER
F 65-69
00:18:36 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:04:28 (2.)
+00:00:28 (+11,7%)
01:04:41 (2.)
+00:07:32 (+13,2%)
01:27:47
+00:04:09 (+5,0%)
92
Swim
00:18:36 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
01:04:41 (2.)
+00:07:32 (+13,2%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Lachlan HARNETT
M 20-24
00:16:34 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:07:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:59:46 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:23:52
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
105
Swim
00:16:34 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:59:46 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Keon MODINI
M 25-29
00:16:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:03:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:59:31 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:19:12
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
131
Swim
00:16:09 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:59:31 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Sean CROTTY
M 30-34
00:17:25 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:03:00 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:58:59 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:19:25
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
126
Swim
00:17:25 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:58:59 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Ty PERRIN
M 35-39
00:14:58 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:03:44 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:56:26 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:15:09
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
160
Swim
00:14:58 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:56:26 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Glen SUSSMAN
M 50-54
00:16:02 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:35 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:54:44 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:13:23
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
181
Swim
00:16:02 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:54:44 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Neil MAKEPEACE
M 55-59

0 Kudos
00:13:40 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:02:24 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:49:52 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:05:56
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
250
Swim
00:13:40 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:49:52 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Rank
 
Name
 
Swim
Difference
T1
Difference
Bike
Difference
Total
Difference
Points
 
1 Claim Ethan FITZSIMMONS
M U16
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:01:56 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
01:00:54
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
290
Swim
00:12:27 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)
Bike
00:46:30 (1.)
+00:00:00 (+0,0%)

Join the Aquabike.World Community

Find every single aquabike race around the world with detailed race informaton
Find all aquabike race results since 2021
Get notficatons about new aquabike races in your state or country by email or in your account notifications
Meet other aquabike athletes
Give Kudos to other athletes for their race results - and recieve Kudos for your achievements
Share your experience - write race reviews about your races
Get updates and news about races, athletes and what´s going on in the world of aquabike racing
Keep updated about your Aquabike.World Ranking
Get a detailed individual Race Report for the races you finish
Download gpx-files of every bike course and ride them virtually on your smart trainer - click here to learn how it works
Optional: Enjoy premium features like our Competitions Analysis, get your Aquabike.World Ranking Certificate, see Benchmarks & Performance Scores, browse comprehensive race statics (see example), get a free aquabike traing plan, enjoy Aquabike.World 100% ad free
... and much more!
Learn more
Share

2 Reviews

  1. Kingscliff Triathlon II 2025 - Olympic Aquabike Race Review

    This review was submitted for Kingscliff Triathlon II 2025 - Olympic Aquabike

    Year of participation: 2025   I participated in Aquabike

    The swim was in the river estuary – clean, water at 22C. As the swim was with tide was fast but also measured only 1.3 km by GPS. The transition was about 200m. Bike course is on good roads. 4 laps, so a few turns at either end. No real gradient but can be blustery with wind. The organisation is excellent, with a friendly atmosphere.

    Overall rating

    Organisation

    The Swim

    Transition

    Bike Course

    Finishline Experience

Leave a Review